Skip to main content

Fixed aperture vs variable aperture zoom lens

As a total beginner, it can be confusing to understand the meaning of F/3.5, F/5.6, F/2.8, etc. written on DSLR camera lenses. Some lenses have two F numbers, while others have only one F-number. So what's the difference between these two lenses? How do they work when changing in-camera settings?
Lenses with single F-number value like F/1.8, F/2.8, F/4, F/5.6 are known as fixed aperture lenses. Fixed aperture lenses are not to be confused with fixed focal length lenses, fixed focal length ones are called prime lenses.  Prime means the lens will only have one focal length, and all the zooming in and out part is done by the user moving physically. On the other hand, lenses with multiple values such as F/3.5-F/5.6, F/3.5-F/4.5, etc. refer to variable aperture zoom lenses. In simple words, these lenses change their widest aperture values when zoomed in or out.

variable aperture vs fixed aperture lens


Example of fixed aperture prime lenses:
Canon EF-S 24 mm F/2.8
Nikon AF-S Nikorr 85 mm F/1.4G
Nikon AF-S DX 35 mm F/1.8G
Canon EF 50 mm F/1.8 STM

Variable aperture zoom lens: F-number changes when zoomed in or zoomed out without user's permission even in Manual mode. The first value is for the lowest zoom, another one is for maximum zoom mentioned on the lens. Example: 
Canon EF-S 18-55 mm EF-S F/3.5-F/5.6
This lens will not allow the camera aperture value of less than F/3.5 at 18 mm focal length. When zoomed into the scene at 50 or 55 mm, the value of F/3.5 will change to F/5.6 due to lens optics limitation. This means in-camera aperture value will stick at a minimum of F/5.6 when zoomed in. In terms of the exposure triangle, this means less light is available to take photos. In terms of background blur (bokeh), this means lesser blur (there are other factors too). Few examples of well known variable aperture zoom lenses include: 
Canon EF 70-300 F/4-F/5.6L IS USM
Canon EF 75-300 F/4-F/5.6 III USM
Canon EF-S 55-250 F/4-F/5.6 IS STM
Canon EF-S 10-18 mm F/4.5-F/5.6 IS STM

Fixed aperture zoom lens: Zoom in or zoom out, the value of F-number will stay the same. Simply, the zoom will have no effect whatsoever on the F-number value unless the user changes it by themselves inside the camera. Few examples of well known fixed aperture zoom lenses include: 
Sigma 17-50 EF-S F/2.8 EX DC OS HSM
Sigma 18-35 f/1.8 DC HSM Art
Canon EF 70-200 F/2.8L IS II USM
Canon EF 24-70 F/2.8L II USM
Tokina AT-X Pro DX II 11-16 F/2.8
Tokina AT-X 11-20 F/2.8 Pro DX
Tokina AT-X 16-28 F/2.8 Pro FX
Canon EF 16-35 F/4L IS USM


Fixed aperture vs variable aperture lens:
Fixed aperture lenses are better as the user does not have to think about aperture getting changed just because focal length was varied. This sometimes leads to poorly exposed shots. Also, fixed aperture makes life a lot easier when shooting a fast-paced event like a wedding, sports, etc. Let's talk about a few points comparing both with each other: 
Sharpness: Fixed aperture lenses are in general more sharp than variable aperture zoom lenses. Also, most of the fixed aperture lenses are made with professional grade quality glass which naturally produces finer images.
Cost: Fixed aperture lenses are more expensive as compared to the equivalent variable aperture zoom lens. Some of the variable aperture zoom lenses are also made professional grade quality glass which makes them more expensive than equivalent lower quality glass variable aperture zoom lens.
Weight: Fixed aperture zoom lenses are heavier as compared to variable aperture DSLR lenses. This is because a lot more amount of glass is used to manufacture fixed aperture lenses.

Hope this post will help you understand your camera lenses in a better way. Share the photography love by sharing this post. :) 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

How to focus at infinity doing night photography?

In the previous post, we talked about taking pictures of the moon with a DSLR. The reason for this post can be contributed to the fact that focusing on the moon is still easier as compared to stars. Also, what to do when you are in the middle of nowhere trying to take pictures of star trails, night sky, milky way, etc. It is hard to see your camera controls on a night without moon and away from city lights. I recently went on a night photography excursion with a group of photographers to do astrophotography. It was pitch dark as there was no moon at all. Here are a few things that worked for most of us when it comes to focusing, pretty sure at least one of them would work for you.
1) Switch to manual mode. Go to live view and zoom in all the way using your camera functionality (not lens). Point it to the brightest star, focus by rotating the focus ring manually. Take a few test shots and see stars by zooming all the way into the photograph.
2) Use magic lantern. This software adds mu…

5 things to know before switching DSLR between Canon and Nikon

Photography is an expensive hobby or profession and everyone wants the best bang for every dollar they spend. This applies to any photography equipment starting with low-cost tripods to super expensive professional grade lenses. I am sure all of us must have heard of Nikon and Canon. The good old battle between these two DSLR brands will never end. Whether you are a beginner or a full time professional, there are a few quirks everyone should know before switching camera between these brands.
1) The used market for Canon gear is just enormous which makes a good plus point for investment and buying decent used gear. Go to craigslist for a given city and search used photography gear, the difference will be easily noticeable. I searched for 10 different cities in Canada and all had comparatively more listings for Canon.
2) Nikon has better dynamic range cameras. Dynamic range is the ability of the camera to sense the lightest and darkest scene in a given photo retaining as much detail as…

How to locate the milky way for night sky DSLR photography?

Our Earth is part of a huge sized galaxy, known as the Milky Way. Milky Way basically consists of our whole solar system and is made up of 100-400 billion stars. Until last year, I had no idea if we can see Milky Way with naked eyes. After a lot of failed late night drives and sleeping at the beach, I was finally able to get a grip on what I actually need to see Milky Way. In September 2016, I got my first Milky Way shot. It was an extremely emotional and priceless moment when I first saw the magnificent milky way with my own eyes. All the failed attempts or discomfort of not going to bed early seemed nothing in that moment. I would consider sharing this priceless memory with fellow photography folks as the inspiration behind this post. 
Moving on to the technical part, there is a minimal amount of gear required to take Milky Way shots using your dslr. Focusing at infinity and calculating the shutter speed to avoid star trails is purely technical, capturing Milky Way takes a little mor…